“Beauty is truth, truth beauty,” — that is all
Ye know on earth, and all ye need to know.
John Keats
-
Recent Posts
Recent Comments
- 15prenticem on Your Poetry
- 15prenticem on Your Poetry
- 15chipmana on Your Poetry
- 15chipmana on Your Poetry
- 15chipmana on Your Poetry
Pages
Archives
Categories
Meta
While I was reading this poem I could really imagine the urn and picture what it looked like through Keats description. This urn has many stories to tell, and I agree with Keats’ opinion that the urn itself reveals truth in its beauty, and it will go on through the centuries to tell its story.
What did you imagine? What stories? Why those particular stories? How does the urn reveal truth in its beauty? Is the urn revealing the truth, or is the poem revealing truth? Why will it go on through the centuries, and why is that significant? Can you leave another reply and be more specific? Dare to eat a peach!
The urn has images of moments that are frozen in time. Through Keats description of the urn I picture the trees that shade the men and women who love each other, and the heifer that awaits its sacrifice. The urn reveals truth in its beauty because it expresses life and eternity. Everyone who will look at this urn through the years will see the urn differently, but the urn itself will always remain the same. The beauty of the urn is that it will reveal different forms of truth to each person who looks at it, because not everyone will imagine the same stories when they look at the images on the urn.
“Ode to a Grecian Urn”
Men lust after untouchable woman, unheard melodies are infinite, beauty never fades, and leaves cease to fall. These pictures that are frozen in time are pure in love and happiness, a symbolic representation of life’s simple truths. The urn is representative of the fact that while our bodies cease to exist, the belief in something larger than ourselves is infinite.
What a lovely thought — beauty is larger than ourselves and can last forever!
The last two lines of the poem about truth and beauty to me hold the meaning of the whole poem, but I don’t really know how this meaning relates back to the urn. The pictures on the urn are probably beautiful and those pictures create scenes and images in both the author and the reader’s minds which are beautiful – that’s where I see the urn coming in.
Your question about the last two lines is an excellent one? See if you can come up with an answer. I look forward to reading your reply.
Separated by thousands of years, the poet takes just as much joy from the art on the urn as the ancient artists did from the art of the musician. This appreciation of beauty is universal, so when it is captured for future generations it holds just as much power as it did at the time of its creation.
While admiring the urn, Keats is aware that the images engraved will remain unchanged even as his own life goes on. Keats knows the characters depicted in the urn will never accomplish anything, but that they will out last him. I feel that to Keats both life and art are beautiful, but only art has immortality while the lives that created them are temporary. The beautiful things people create last, but not people themselves.
The things described in the poem have all been lost in history, but the beauty remains as a part of eternity. The beauty arouse in people wonders and the desires to seek truth. However, while people are seeking truth, they realize that they are mortals overall. Truth, on the other hand, is infinite and immortal. The correlation between truth and beauty is clear now because they both last forever and they both intrigue people. The more people search for both, the more they realize that the borderline between them is undefined or undefinable. Eventually, people will find truth in beauty, and beauty in truth.
Though Keats mostly contrasts the immortal beauty of the paintings with the constant change of human life, he subtly hints that he cannot conceive any beauty to be constant, even the beauty in the paintings. He describes that the painted scene “haunts about [the urn’s] shape,” gravely creating the image of some spirit bound forever to one place. In describing the scene of the sacrifice, he regretfully says, “And little town, thy streets for evermore/ Will silent be; and not a soul, to tell/ Why thou art desolate, can e’er return.” Keats even describes the whole painting on the urn as a “Cold Pastoral,” paradoxically stating that even eternal beauty wears out simply due to the effects of time. This reflection is reminiscent of the beautiful sea nymph Thetis’s envy of her son Achilles because of his mortality, for it made the time he was alive so much sweeter than her endless life. The Buddha, too, taught that understanding the impermanence of everything leads to bliss, and the Chinese concept of yin and yang describe the interdependence of contrasting phenomena in shaping experience. Perhaps Keats also believes we can only experience beauty through its contrast with the unbeautiful.
When reading this poem, I stretch my arm to touch the urn. A thin layer of melancholy soon reveals itself, surrounds my hand. The lover will never kiss; The heifer is locked into her helpless destiny; And the town is forever silent. If instant is eternal, then the order of it all is beauty. With the same material, the urn can be ugly. But the order of the material makes it a beauty, which is locked into eternity in an instant.
In the way that I read the poem, I felt that the poet was not admiring a single Grecian urn, but rather several, each portraying a different myth, some joyous and even comedic, while others had a very melancholy and tragic feel to them. The meaning of this poem was to give the reader an idea of the beauty of the Grecian urns with their many stories without a single word. It is to express how much can by said by saying nothing and how you find truth in beauty and through its simplicity, beauty in truth.